docs: excessive-entities page

i18n/en/docusaurus-plugin-content-docs/current/guides/issues/excessive-entities.md

@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
+# Excessive Entities
+
+The `entities` layer in Feature-Sliced Design is one of the lower layers that's primarily for business logic. That makes it widely accessible — all layers except for `shared` can access it. However, its global nature means that changes to `entities` can have a widespread impact, requiring careful design to avoid costly refactors.
+
+Excessive entities can lead to ambiguity (what code belongs to this layer), coupling, and constant import dilemmas (code scattered across sibling entities).
+
+## How to keep `entities` layer clean
+
+### 0. Consider having no `entities` layer
+
+You might think that your application won't be Feature-Sliced if you don't include this layer, but it is completely fine for the application to have no `entities` layer. It doesn't break FSD in any way, on the contrary, it simplifies the architecture and keeps the `entities` layer available for future scaling. For example, if your application acts as a thin client, most likely it doesn't need `entities` layer.
+
+:::info[What are thick and thin clients?]
+
+_Thick_ vs. _thin client_ distinction refers to how the application processes data:
+
+- _Thin_ clients rely on the backend for most data processing. Client-side business logic is minimal and involves only exchanging data with the backend.
+- _Thick_ clients handle significant client-side business logic, making them suitable candidates for the `entities` layer.
+
+Keep in mind that this classification is not strictly binary, and different parts of the same application may act as a "thick" or a "thin" client.
+
+:::
+
+### 1. Avoid preemptive slicing
+
+In contrast to previous versions, FSD 2.1 encourages deferred decomposition of slices instead of preemptive, and this approach also extends to `entities` layer. At first, you can place all your code in the `model` segment of your page (widget, feature), and then consider refactoring it later, when business requirements are stable. Remember: it is much easier and safer to move something into `entities` later, than refactor code inside `entities` that can affect any upper level slice functionality.
+
+### 2. Avoid Unnecessary Entities
+
+Do not create an entity for every piece of business logic. Instead, leverage types from `shared/api` and place logic in the `model` segment of a current slice. For reusable business logic, use the `model` segment within an entity slice while keeping data definitions in `shared/api`:
+
+```plaintext
+📂 entities
+  📂 order
+    📄 index.ts
+    📂 model
+      📄 apply-discount.ts // Business logic using OrderDto from shared/api
+📂 shared
+  📂 api
+    📄 index.ts
+    📂 endpoints
+      📄 order.ts
+```
+
+### 3. Exclude CRUD Operations from Entities
+
+CRUD operations, while essential, often involve boilerplate code without significant business logic. Including them in the `entities` layer can clutter it and obscure meaningful code. Instead, place CRUD operations in `shared/api`:
+
+```plaintext
+📂 shared
+  📂 api
+    📄 client.ts
+    📄 index.ts
+    📂 endpoints
+      📄 order.ts // Contains all order-related CRUD operations
+      📄 products.ts
+      📄 cart.ts
+```
+
+For complex CRUD operations (e.g., atomic updates, rollbacks, or transactions), evaluate whether the `entities` layer is appropriate, but use it with caution.
+
+### 4. Store Authentication Data in `shared`
+
+Prefer `shared` layer to creating a `user` entity for authentication data, such as tokens or user DTOs returned from the backend. These are context-specific and unlikely to be reused outside authentication scope:
+
+- Authentication responses (e.g., tokens or DTOs) often lack fields needed for broader reuse or vary by context (e.g., private vs. public user profiles).
+- Using entities for auth data can lead to cross-layer imports (e.g., `entities` into `shared`) or usage of `@x` notation, complicating the architecture.
+
+Instead, store authentication-related data in `shared/auth` or `shared/api`:
+
+```plaintext
+📂 shared
+  📂 auth
+    📄 use-auth.ts // authenticated user info or token
+    📄 index.ts
+  📂 api
+    📄 client.ts
+    📄 index.ts
+    📂 endpoints
+      📄 order.ts
+```
+
+### 5. Minimize Cross-Imports
+
+FSD permits cross-imports via `@x` notation, but they can introduce technical issues like circular dependencies. To avoid this, design entities within isolated business contexts to eliminate the need for cross-imports:
+
+Non-Isolated Business Context (Avoid):
+
+```plaintext
+📂 entities
+  📂 order
+    📂 @x
+    📂 model
+  📂 order-item
+    📂 @x
+    📂 model
+  📂 order-customer-info
+    📂 @x
+    📂 model
+```
+
+Isolated Business Context (Preferred):
+
+```plaintext
+📂 entities
+  📂 order-info
+    📄 index.ts
+    📂 model
+      📄 order-info.ts
+```
+
+An isolated context encapsulates all related logic (e.g., order items and customer info) within a single module, reducing complexity and preventing external modifications to tightly coupled logic.